Can Audits Backfire?

Auditing processes are intended to simply monitor compliance with existing rules. However, they may by themselves sometimes create unintended impacts and incentives through the specific protocol by which audits are executed. This paper investigates the effects of 2011 and 2012 audits in Chile on public entities’ subsequent public procurement practices. While the national procurement legislation tries to promote the use of more transparent and competitive auctions rather than the more discretionary direct contracts for selection of public procurement suppliers, the audit protocol of the national comptroller agency mechanically leads to more scrutiny and a higher probability of further investigation for auctions than for direct contracts. This can create a disincentive for the use of auctions.

Contradictory incentives

Using a regression discontinuity design based on a scoring rule of the national auditing agency, we find that indeed being audited leads public entities to decrease their use of auctions and increase the use of direct contracts correspondingly. In order to further test the underlying mechanism, we develop a new econometric approach to conduct subgroup analysis in regression discontinuity designs while holding other observables constant.

open close
Overview
Status
Preliminary results
Country
Chile
Program area
Political Economy and Governance, Public Finance, Political Economy
Topics
Auditing, Public Procurement, RDD,, Public Policy, Public Finance
Partners
Swedish Research Council, Program for Development Research, SIDA, J-PAL, William F. Milton Fund at Harvard Medical School, Harvard Center for Population and Development Studies
Study type
Econometric analysis (regression discontinuity design)
open close
Researchers
Maria Paula Gerardino
Inter-American Development Bank
Stephan Litschig
National Graduate Institute for Policy Studies
Dina Pomeranz
Zurich CED

see all affiliates

Involved partners

SwissRe
UZH

Similar research

Public-Finance, Political-Economy
No Taxation without Information
finance
Saving More in Groups
Political-Economy-and-Governance, Public-Finance, Political-Economy
Dodging the Taxman