Competition in Agricultural Markets

The degree to which intermediaries compete is a long-standing object of interest in studies of agricultural markets in developing countries. Competition shapes how price signals propagate along supply chains, and the welfare implications of taxes and subsidies for producers and consumers. However, the evidence is remarkably thin. In the limited cases where conclusions can be drawn, the researchers see a high degree of competition. On the other hand, governments and international institutions often emphasize the monopsonistic power of traders. Previous studies of competition in these markets have primarily relied on observational data, analyzing trader price-cost margins, price dispersion across space, or the pass-through of international prices along the supply chain. In contrast, we propose an experimental approach for estimating the degree of competition.

Shedding light on market structure

Our experiment is based on the randomization of unit subsidies to competing traders for their purchases from farmers. By comparing prices that subsidized and unsubsidized traders pay to farmers, we can recover the rate of differentiation between traders, the key market structure parameter in a standard model of oligopsonistic competition. By combining the experimental results with quasi-experimental estimates of the pass-through rate, we also estimate market size, or the effective number of traders competing for farmers’ supply.

In the context of the Sierra Leone cocoa industry, our results point to a competitive agricultural trading sector and suggest that the market size is substantially larger than the village. The methodology developed in this study uses purely individual-level treatment to shed light on market structure. This approach may be useful for the many cases where market-level randomization is not feasible.

open close
Overview
Status
Results
Country
Sierra Leone
Program area
agriculture, finance
Topics
Agricultural markets, Competition, field experiments, interlinked transactions, intermediaries
Partners
Innovations for Poverty Action
Study type
Experiment, quasi-experimental estimates
open close
Researchers
Lorenzo Casaburi
Zurich CED
Tristan Reed
World Bank

see all affiliates

Involved partners

SwissRe
UZH

Similar research

agriculture, finance
Time vs. State in Insurance
agriculture, finance
Firm and Market Response to Saving Constraints
agriculture
Lemon Technologies and Adoption